Full review
Longer notes from the same comments we summarized above.
What people reported
The cupped key wells are a standout feature, with many owners reporting that they make reaching upper and lower keys effortless from the home row. The thumb-cluster keys for important functions like backspace, delete, enter, and space are also consistently highlighted as a "best feature," greatly enhancing efficiency and comfort. Owners who adapted to the keyboard often found their typing experience significantly improved, with some even switching to alternative layouts like Dvorak or Workman. The keyboard is also praised for its programmability, allowing users to customize key mappings.
Problems people mention
One of the most frequent comments is about the significant learning curve required to master the Advantage2. Some users noted that adapting back to a standard keyboard after prolonged use of the Kinesis can also be challenging. A notable concern for professionals is the lack of a dedicated numerical pad, which many find to be a "no-go." The keyboard's thickness and single-piece design are also mentioned as drawbacks, making the typing position too high for some desks and limiting portability compared to split keyboards. There's a desire for more modern updates, such as a refreshed look, "real keys" for the top row, and more switch options like MX Clears. The high price also makes some potential buyers hesitant.
Where owners disagree
Opinions diverge on the keyboard's overall size and suitability for different hand sizes; some expressed concern that their hands might not be large enough. While many appreciate the deep ergonomic design, some found the thickness to be a hindrance to their desk setup, leading them to use it less often. There isn't significant disagreement on features, but rather on how personal needs and desk setups align with the keyboard's specific design.
Who it's for
The Kinesis Advantage2 is best for individuals prioritizing advanced ergonomics and those willing to invest time in adapting to a unique layout. It particularly suits typists using Dvorak or Workman layouts, or anyone looking to alleviate or prevent repetitive strain injuries. However, it may not be ideal for users who frequently need a numerical pad, prefer split keyboards for portability, or are on a strict budget. Those with smaller hands might want to try it first if possible.
