Full review
Longer notes from the same comments we summarized above.
What people reported
Owners generally describe the Magic Keyboard as "very nice" with a "better feeling keys" compared to some alternatives. The integrated Touch ID is a key feature, providing convenient security for authentication. Some users appreciate the availability of a version with a numeric keypad. At least one owner successfully cleaned coffee out of their keyboard and repaired a few scissor switches.
Problems people mention
A recurring concern is the high price of the keyboard, with many considering it "overpriced." A significant limitation is that the Touch ID feature only works with Apple Silicon Macs (M1 chip or later). This means it is not compatible with older Intel-based iMacs or other non-M1 Apple devices for Touch ID functionality. Another common complaint is the absence of backlighting for the keys. Some older Magic Keyboards (not necessarily this specific model with Touch ID) have been reported to develop connection issues, scratches, or become bent over time, raising durability questions for the product line generally.
Where owners disagree
While many comments confirm the Touch ID works with M1 devices, one user reported that they "can't use the Touch ID with my M1 Macbook Air." This suggests that while M1 compatibility is generally expected, individual setup or specific M1 models might encounter issues. The overall usefulness of external Touch ID is also a point of mild contention, as some M1 Mac owners note their Apple Watch already handles Mac unlocking, reducing the need for the keyboard's Touch ID feature.
Who it's for
This keyboard is best suited for users with an Apple Silicon Mac (M1 or newer) who want the convenience of Touch ID directly on their keyboard for secure authentication. It also appeals to those who prioritize a comfortable typing experience and prefer a dedicated numeric keypad option. Potential buyers should be aware of the lack of backlighting and the higher price point.
