Full review
Longer notes from the same comments we summarized above.
What we learned from owners
Owners stepping into the Salomon X Ultra 5 GTX have a mix of experiences, often comparing it to its predecessors. Many appreciate the grippy Salomon sole and the lightweight feel that the X Ultra line is known for, making them suitable for everyday use and shorter mountain hikes. Some loyal users, having owned multiple generations, find them comfortable and reliable.
Common problems reported
A significant concern for the X Ultra 5 GTX is its fit. Several owners report that the boots are very narrow, sometimes making it difficult to even get their feet in, despite having worn the same size in previous X Ultra models. This narrowness, combined with a stiff ankle area, can lead to rubbing and discomfort. There are also durability concerns echoed from earlier X Ultra models, with reports of the Gore-Tex membrane wearing out and soles detaching, particularly in hot and humid climates. This raises questions about the long-term resilience of the X Ultra 5. Furthermore, despite the GTX membrane, some users note that waterproofing isn't always reliable, with feet getting wet even in minor damp conditions.
Where opinions differ
Opinions diverge significantly on comfort and waterproofing. While some find the X Ultra 5 GTX comfortable enough for daily dog walks and general use, others experience substantial heel discomfort or blisters on hikes exceeding 8 miles. Similarly, the effectiveness of the Gore-Tex waterproofing is a point of contention; some hope the 5s improve upon the 4s, which many found allowed moisture in.
Should you buy it?
The Salomon X Ultra 5 GTX offers a good blend of agility and reliable traction that many hikers seek. However, the reported narrow fit and potential for ankle rubbing or stiffness make trying them on absolutely essential before purchase, especially if you have wider feet or are accustomed to the fit of older X Ultra generations. If you're planning demanding multi-day trips or frequently encounter very wet conditions, historical concerns about durability and waterproofing effectiveness should be carefully weighed. These boots could be a strong contender for those who find them comfortable and prioritize a lightweight, grippy shoe, but be aware of the potential trade-offs regarding fit and long-term resilience.
