Full review
Longer notes from the same comments we summarized above.
What we learned from owners
Owners consistently highlight the Leatherman Signal's focus on outdoor and survival tasks. Many appreciate having a built-in ferro rod for fire starting and a whistle for signaling, considering these vital for camping, hiking, and emergency situations. Its tail hammer is also noted as a useful addition. Users carrying it daily for wilderness activities like parks patrol or search and rescue (SAR) find it to be a good size and weight, and some have reported that it holds up well to years of use.
Common problems reported
A recurring complaint among owners is the absence of scissors, which many users find essential in a multi-tool. There's also a clear preference for a plain-edge blade over the standard serrated/combo blade. Some ergonomic issues surfaced: the diamond sharpener's placement can make it uncomfortable to grip the tool, and the overall body design can feel "erratic" or hurt when pressed hard. The ferro rod, while appreciated, is sometimes described as "anemic" or small, and the rod and whistle assembly can feel loose and rattle. A few owners mentioned that the pliers feel weak, and there were some implied issues with the bit driver's stability.
Where opinions differ
Opinions on the Signal are quite divided, largely depending on its intended use. Some users love it and wouldn't leave home without it for their outdoor adventures, even calling it the "best multi tool ever made." Others strongly disagree, labeling it a "boy scout toy" or "the silliest Leatherman" if not specifically used for wilderness tasks. Its value for money is also a point of contention; some feel it's overpriced for what it offers, particularly if its unique survival features aren't a priority. The effectiveness of the ferro rod sometimes depends on the user's skill, leading to differing experiences.
Should you buy it?
If you're looking for a multi-tool specifically tailored for wilderness, survival, hiking, or camping, the Leatherman Signal could be a good fit, thanks to its unique integrated fire starter and whistle. However, if your needs lean more towards a general-purpose multi-tool for everyday tasks, DIY projects, or heavy-duty work, you might find its specialized features come at the cost of other, more commonly desired tools like scissors, or a plain-edge blade. Consider your primary use case carefully before committing to the Signal.
