Full review
Longer notes from the same comments we summarized above.
What we learned from owners
Owners consistently praise the Merrell Moab 3 Low GTX for its exceptional comfort right out of the box, often highlighting that it requires no break-in period. Many describe them as "super comfortable" and a "perfect 10" for daily wear and general hiking. For those with broader feet, the availability of wide sizes is a significant plus, with some calling them "game changing" for comfort. The shoes are also noted for being suitable for various terrains and everyday use.
Common problems reported
The most significant and recurring issue reported by owners is inconsistent waterproofing. Despite being a GTX (Gore-Tex) model, several users experienced the shoes leaking and getting wet toes, sometimes after as little as a year of use. One owner even sarcastically noted they "literally absorb water above the sole." Another common complaint is that the soles are too flexible for more demanding activities like scrambling on sharp, rocky ridgelines, which can lead to foot soreness. There's also a specific mention of the synthetic lining developing an unpleasant odor quickly, even with clean feet and socks. Some general feedback on Merrell shoes also points to durability concerns, with toes peeling away from the sole over time.
Where opinions differ
Opinions strongly differ on the waterproofing capability of the Moab 3 Low GTX. While a notable number of users reported leaks and a complete lack of waterproofing, others explicitly stated that the Gore-Tex models performed "very waterproof below zero" and were "great in rain and snow hikes in winter." This suggests a potential quality control issue or varying expectations and conditions of use.
Should you buy it?
If you're looking for a hiking shoe that prioritizes immediate comfort and works well for daily wear and moderate trails, the Merrell Moab 3 Low GTX is highly regarded by many owners. However, if reliable waterproofing is crucial for your adventures or if you frequently tackle challenging, rocky terrain requiring stiff sole support, you should consider the mixed feedback on these specific aspects. Be aware of the potential for inconsistent waterproofing and flexible soles that may not offer enough support for demanding hikes.
