Full review
Longer notes from the same comments we summarized above.
What people reported
Owners report that the Starling Home Hub provided seamless integration for Google and Nest devices into Apple HomeKit. This allowed them to control various devices, including Nest cameras, doorbells, thermostats, and smoke detectors, directly through the Apple Home app. Many appreciated the ability to control Nest thermostats using Siri and to set up schedules and automations within the Apple Home ecosystem. The hub also enabled HomePod Minis to announce doorbell presses, a feature users found valuable. It was noted to work with a mix of both older Nest products and newer Google Nest rebranded devices, addressing concerns about broad device support.
Problems people mention
The most significant issue by far is that the Starling Home Hub is no longer produced or available for purchase. This has caused considerable frustration among potential buyers who have already invested in Google/Nest devices and are looking for a HomeKit solution. Another concern is the tedious setup process required for existing devices. Users with many installed Nest/Google products found the need to re-scan each device time-consuming and challenging, especially for those mounted in hard-to-reach locations. Additionally, the hub does not extend HomeKit compatibility to non-Nest smart lights or other Google Home compatible devices. There was also some unclarity regarding whether a Nest Aware subscription remains necessary for certain features after integration.
Where owners disagree
There is limited evidence to suggest significant disagreement among owners regarding the Starling Home Hub's functionality. The primary point of contention revolves around the product's unavailability rather than its performance or features.
Who it's for
The Starling Home Hub was ideal for Apple HomeKit users who possessed an existing ecosystem of Google/Nest devices. It was designed for those seeking to unify their smart home experience, enabling central control and advanced automations through Apple's platform. However, due to its discontinuation, it is no longer a viable option for new buyers.
