Full review
Longer notes from the same comments we summarized above.
What people reported
Owners report that the AeroGarden Harvest XL, and AeroGarden systems in general, are effective for growing a wide range of plants. Many users successfully achieve their first harvests and find the system great for starting herbs, leafy greens, and even some root vegetables. The system is often described as easy to use, with features like simple nutrition protocols and customizable light settings. One owner noted that the Harvest XL's pump might be very quiet or even silent, asking if this was normal, implying minimal operational noise. The light system on the XL is also effective, with its additional wattage covering the light height adequately for seedlings.
Problems people mention
A notable concern among owners is the longevity of the pumps, with one owner reporting having to replace pumps three times in each of their four AeroGardens after about a year and a half. This owner also experienced plants growing slowly or not at all, despite regular maintenance. Some users find it difficult to germinate their own seeds in the system, suggesting that AeroGarden's proprietary seed pods might be more reliable. A significant concern raised by one owner is the future of the AeroGarden company, stating it is going out of business and will only sell accessories on Amazon, which could impact the availability of parts and support. This also ties into a general perception among some that newer models (referred to as "2.0") feel "dumbed down" or cheaper.
Where owners disagree
There isn't a strong disagreement among owners, but a question arose regarding the Harvest XL's pump noise. One owner asked if it was normal for the pump to make "no noise at all," suggesting a potential ambiguity on whether silence is a feature or a malfunction. This contrasts with general expectations of a slight hum from pumps. There was also a minor discussion about whether Elite models have different light wattage or if perceived brightness is due to stainless steel reflection.
Who it's for
The AeroGarden Harvest XL is a good choice for new and experienced gardeners looking for an easy-to-use indoor hydroponic system. It suits those who want to grow herbs, small vegetables, or germinate seeds indoors, especially if they value a quiet operation. However, potential buyers should be aware of the reported issues with pump longevity and consider the implications of concerns around company support and parts availability for long-term use.
