Full review
Longer notes from the same comments we summarized above.
What people reported
Owners consistently describe the Concept2 RowErg as exceptionally durable and long-lasting. Many reported their machines lasting decades, with some citing models from 2002 and even 1999 still working great after millions of meters. The PM5 monitor is a significant highlight, frequently called "head and shoulders above" other monitors due to its "precision metrics" and "tremendous functionality." It allows for tracking separate users and is key to engaging in global competitions and challenges within a large community.
The RowErg is widely seen as the "gold standard" and the "go-to training machine for world class rowers" and "collegiate athletes." Users also appreciate the strong community that participates in Concept2 challenges, along with the availability of affordable replacement parts directly from the company. It's often considered "reasonably priced" given its quality, especially compared to more expensive smart rowers, offering good long-term value. While it lacks built-in smart features, many owners see this as a positive, noting "less to break" and the ability to add smart functionality via external apps like EXR, which can be a cheaper subscription option.
Problems people mention
Some owners reported that the seat can be hard and cause "tired butt" during longer workouts. This issue, however, is easily resolved by adding a foam rubber pad. The noise level of the machine is another point of concern for some, who describe it as loud enough for neighbors to hear.
Where owners disagree
There is disagreement regarding the machine's noise output. While some users find it "pretty quiet," describing the sound as a "hum" rather than a loud sloshing like water rowers, others perceive it as distinctly loud. On the topic of smart features, some initially view the lack of built-in smarts as a drawback. However, many owners counter that the absence of integrated smart tech means "less to break" and that external apps offer a more flexible and often cheaper way to get smart functionality.
Who it's for
The Concept2 RowErg is ideal for individuals seeking a highly durable, reliable, and effective rowing machine for serious training. It particularly appeals to competitive rowers, athletes, and fitness enthusiasts who prioritize accurate performance metrics, a strong user community, and long-term value over built-in interactive screens or silent operation. It's also suitable for those who prefer the flexibility of adding smart features via their own devices and apps.
