Reliability score
Compared side by side
Apple Magic Mouse vs Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse
Reliability scores
Reliability score
Scores compared
Pulled from each product’s full review.
- Reliability
- 67 / 100
- 65 / 100
- Estimated 3-year upkeep Parts and repairs, rough estimate
-
Apple Magic Mouse
Calibrating maintenance feedback
-
Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse
Calibrating maintenance feedback
Pros and cons
Good and bad, as each full review tells it.
Apple Magic Mouse
Strengths
- Sleek, attractive design that integrates well with Apple devices.
- Supports multi-touch gestures for intuitive scrolling and swiping.
- Wireless Bluetooth connectivity with easy setup.
- Long-lasting rechargeable battery.
Concerns
- Poor ergonomics for extended use, with some finding it uncomfortable to hold.
- Multi-touch surface can lead to accidental inputs when resting fingers or clicking.
- Lacks a dedicated middle mouse button, which hinders some workflows and gaming.
- Physical design can be susceptible to damage, affecting click functionality.
Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse
Strengths
- Owners found it pleasant to hold.
Concerns
- Some users reported a weak or inaccurate sensor.
- It is perceived as overpriced by some owners.
The verdict
Our bottom line after lining up both full reviews.
Bottom line
Your choice depends on whether you prioritize Apple's unique multi-touch gestures or a more traditionally comfortable and eco-friendly design.
Key takeaways
- Choose the Apple Magic Mouse for deep macOS integration and gesture control.
- Opt for the Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse if ergonomic comfort and sustainability are your main concerns.
- Neither mouse is ideal for precision tasks or extended, heavy daily use due to their respective drawbacks.
Performance
The Apple Magic Mouse offers intuitive multi-touch gestures that integrate seamlessly with macOS, making scrolling and navigating very fluid. However, its flat design often leads to ergonomic challenges during long work sessions. The Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse provides a more traditional, comfortable feel in hand, though some owners report issues with its sensor's accuracy, which can affect everyday tasks.
Durability
Owners of the Apple Magic Mouse do not report significant structural durability issues, but its unique charging port placement is a common point of frustration. The Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse is made from recycled materials, which is a positive for many. Early feedback for the Microsoft mouse is limited, so long-term durability is less clear, but no widespread defects have emerged.
Community sentiment
The Apple Magic Mouse is praised for its elegant design and sophisticated gestures, yet it receives frequent complaints about hand strain and its inconvenient charging method. The Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse is appreciated for its comfortable shape and sustainable build. However, some users express concerns about its tracking precision and perceive it as overpriced for its feature set.
Key differences
Where the two products differ on the same everyday points owners care about.
Ergonomics and Comfort
Better here: Microsoft Ocean Plastic MouseApple Magic Mouse
Owners frequently find the Apple Magic Mouse's flat profile uncomfortable for extended periods, leading to hand fatigue.
Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse
The Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse offers a more sculpted, traditional shape that many users find more comfortable to hold.
Multi-Touch Gestures
Better here: Apple Magic MouseApple Magic Mouse
The Apple Magic Mouse excels with its smooth, customizable multi-touch gestures that are deeply integrated with macOS.
Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse
The Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse features standard left/right clicks and a scroll wheel, lacking advanced gesture capabilities.
Charging Convenience
Better here: Microsoft Ocean Plastic MouseApple Magic Mouse
The Apple Magic Mouse charges via a Lightning port on its underside, making it unusable while plugged in.
Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse
The Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse uses AA batteries, offering easy replacement but no rechargeable built-in option.
The compromise
What you give up when you pick one over the other.
If you choose Apple Magic Mouse
If you choose the Apple Magic Mouse, you might sacrifice traditional ergonomic comfort and face frustration with its charging design. It's not the best option if you need to use your mouse for many hours straight.
If you choose Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse
Opting for the Microsoft Ocean Plastic Mouse means you will miss out on the fluid multi-touch gestures specific to Apple's ecosystem. Some users also report less precise sensor performance, which could impact certain tasks.